Quake Media

QUAKE MEDIA / THE PRACTICAL GUIDE

SEO Audit Tools: Choose the Right Tool for the Job

Choose an SEO audit tool by the question you need answered. Quake's free page audit checks nine on-page signals on one public page, Google Search Console shows search and indexing evidence, Screaming Frog crawls for site-wide issues, free for up to 500 URLs, and PageSpeed Insights diagnoses speed with lab and real-user data.

Explore the guide

Published · Updated · 4 minute read

THE BIG PICTURE

One question. The right evidence.

01Page checks
02Site-wide diagnosis
03A useful action plan

A framework for the decisions in this guide.

Page checks / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

Which SEO audit tool do you actually need?

Choose an SEO audit tool according to the question you need answered. A quick page review, a site-wide crawl, a Google indexing investigation and a speed diagnosis are different jobs. Start with the smallest useful check, then investigate the evidence behind its findings. A high score does not establish that a page targets the right customers or generates enquiries.

This is a task-based comparison, not a paid ranking of vendors or a claim that one product can diagnose everything. Quake Media provides the free page audit listed here. The other tools are independent products; their official documentation is linked below. Features and access limits can change, so confirm them before buying a subscription.

Match the question to the audit
Your questionStart hereImportant limit
Are this page’s basic SEO signals present?Quake’s free SEO analysis toolOne public page, not a full crawl
How does Google see my pages?Google Search ConsoleRequires property access
Where are site-wide link and metadata problems?Screaming Frog SEO SpiderCrawl settings and plan affect coverage
Why is this page slow?PageSpeed InsightsLab results and real-user data answer different questions

Site-wide diagnosis / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

A free SEO analysis tool for your first pass

Use our free SEO audit and analysis tool to review a public-facing page before deciding what needs a deeper investigation. It checks nine on-page signals and produces a readable report. Start with a page that should generate business: your core service, a location page or a product category. Reviewing only the homepage can miss problems specific to another template.

Read the explanation behind each finding. A missing description is a different issue from an inaccessible page, and neither automatically explains a traffic decline. Save the audited URL with your notes so the person implementing changes knows exactly what was tested. Email is requested when saving or printing the report; the initial review is available without buying a service.

This tool does not connect to your private analytics, inspect every URL, verify conversion tracking or establish backlink quality. It is a starting point for discussion. If your question is why thousands of pages disappeared from search, use the indexing and crawl investigations below rather than treating a single-page score as the answer.

A useful action plan / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

Search Console: actual search and indexing evidence

Google Search Console’s Performance report shows search clicks, impressions and the queries and pages associated with that activity. Use a page filter before reviewing its queries. Two separate top-ten lists do not prove that the first query belongs to the first page.

For a page with impressions but no clicks, examine its position, countries, devices and search intent before rewriting its title. Compare equivalent periods and record substantial site changes. A seven-day sample can reveal a broken destination, but usually cannot explain a lasting trend on its own. Search Console is valuable evidence from Google Search, not a substitute for checking what visitors do after arriving.

Page checks / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

Screaming Frog: a broader SEO site audit

Screaming Frog SEO Spider is a desktop crawler for inspecting site-wide issues such as broken links, redirects, titles and descriptions. Its free version allows a crawl of up to 500 URLs; advanced capabilities depend on the licence. Check the vendor’s current feature list against your requirements rather than assuming every function is available free.

Begin with the canonical domain and choose crawl settings deliberately. Review whether filters, parameter URLs or a store’s faceted navigation are creating unnecessary requests. For a redesign, compare the discovered URLs with your sitemap and migration inventory. A crawler reports what it discovers under those settings; pages with no links may need to be supplied separately.

Export actionable findings with the affected URL, issue, intended destination and owner. A list of several hundred warnings is only useful when someone distinguishes a site-wide template defect from a harmless exception.

Site-wide diagnosis / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

PageSpeed Insights: speed evidence with context

PageSpeed Insights combines Lighthouse lab diagnostics with real-user data where enough measurements are available. Use the lab report to investigate loading and layout problems. Treat field data as a view of actual visitors over its reporting window, not an immediate confirmation of a change made today.

Check representative page types on mobile and desktop. A lightweight article and an interactive portfolio can expose different bottlenecks. Record the test conditions, page version and consent state. If an image is too large, reduce its delivered dimensions or weight; if content moves during loading, reserve the space it needs. Recheck the relevant behaviour after the correction.

A useful action plan / EXPLORE THE DETAILS

When should you hire an SEO audit agency?

A tool gathers evidence. An SEO audit company should interpret it, connect it to commercial priorities and define what happens next. Ask for sample deliverables showing affected URLs, the reasoning behind each recommendation, implementation responsibility and a way to confirm the fix. Establish whether development work is included or quoted separately.

Bring in help when the problem spans templates, indexing, migrations, customer intent or measurement. An audit should distinguish urgent access failures from improvements that can wait. Explore our SEO audit services, use the technical SEO checklist, or send us the page and the problem. For agency-branded client reporting, our white-label audit-tool guide covers a different selection problem.

FROM READING TO DOING

Make your next
move a clear one.

Bring us your goals and the questions this guide raised. We’ll help you work out what belongs in your plan.

Talk it through with Quake